Policy on the Use of Generative Artificial

Delta: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika is committed to maintaining transparency, accountability, confidentiality, and integrity throughout the scholarly publication process. This policy regulates the use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and AI-assisted technologies by authors, the Editorial Team, and peer reviewers.

This policy applies to manuscripts, supplementary files, datasets, figures, revision documents, responses to reviewers, editorial correspondence, and peer-review reports submitted to or processed by the journal.

1. Use of Generative AI by Authors

1.1 Authorship and Accountability

Generative AI tools, large language models, chatbots, and other AI-assisted technologies cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot take responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, originality, and ethical implications of scholarly work.

Authors remain fully responsible for all content submitted to Delta: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika, including any text, translation, analysis, computer code, table, figure, image, reference, or other material produced or modified with AI assistance.

Authors must critically review, edit, and verify all AI-assisted content before submission. In particular, authors are responsible for verifying:

  • The factual and conceptual accuracy of the content;
  • The accuracy of mathematical notation, formulas, calculations, and statistical results;
  • The existence, relevance, and accuracy of all citations and references;
  • The originality of the manuscript;
  • The validity of interpretations and conclusions; and
  • Compliance with research ethics, copyright, privacy, and data-protection requirements.

AI-generated output must not replace the authors’ scholarly judgment, mathematical reasoning, critical analysis, or intellectual contribution.

1.2 Permitted Uses

Authors may use GenAI or AI-assisted technologies for legitimate supporting purposes, including:

  • Translation;
  • Grammar, spelling, and punctuation correction;
  • Improvement of readability, coherence, and academic language;
  • Assistance in organizing or outlining a manuscript;
  • Coding or programming assistance; and
  • Data processing or analysis when methodologically justified, transparently reported, and independently validated by the authors.

The use of AI must remain under direct human supervision and must not determine the final scientific interpretation or conclusion of the study.

When GenAI is used as part of the research method or as the object of research the authors must describe the tool, version, prompts or procedures, date of access, validation process, and limitations in sufficient detail to support transparency and reproducibility.

1.3 Prohibited Uses

Authors must not use GenAI or AI-assisted technologies to:

  • Fabricate, falsify, or manipulate research data, participant responses, findings, quotations, references, images, or other research materials;
  • Generate false, unverifiable, irrelevant, or misleading citations;
  • Produce fictitious mathematical solutions, statistical results, or empirical evidence;
  • Conceal plagiarism, duplicate publication, image manipulation, or other forms of academic misconduct;
  • Misrepresent AI-generated content as entirely human-generated scholarly work;
  • Replace essential human judgment in research design, data interpretation, ethical assessment, or scientific decision-making; or
  • Infringe copyright, intellectual-property rights, privacy rights, or applicable research-ethics requirements.

Authors must not upload confidential or identifiable research materials (including student identities, student work, questionnaire responses, interview transcripts, classroom recordings, or unpublished institutional data) to publicly accessible AI platforms without appropriate consent, ethical authorization, and adequate data-protection safeguards.

AI-generated or AI-modified images must not be presented as authentic empirical evidence. Their use is permitted only when image generation or modification is part of the research method or object of study and is clearly identified and methodologically explained.

2. Mandatory Disclosure by Authors

Authors must disclose any use of GenAI or AI-assisted technologies that generated, translated, analyzed, substantially revised, or materially influenced the manuscript.

The disclosure must include:

  • The name and version of the AI tool, when available;
  • The developer or provider of the tool;
  • The specific purpose for which the tool was used;
  • The parts of the manuscript or research process affected;
  • The extent of the AI contribution; and
  • The procedures used to review, verify, and validate the AI-assisted output.

Depending on the nature of its use, the disclosure must be included in:

  • The Acknowledgements section, when AI was used for translation, proofreading, or general language improvement;
  • The Methods section, when AI was used for coding, data processing, data analysis, classification, image generation, or another methodological procedure;
  • The relevant figure or table caption, when AI was used to generate or substantially modify a figure, image, illustration, or table; and/or
  • A separate Declaration of Generative AI Use placed before the References section.

Disclosure of AI use does not transfer responsibility from the authors to the AI tool, its developer, or the journal.

Example of a General Disclosure Statement

Declaration of Generative AI Use: During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used ChatGPT for translation, language refinement, and coherence enhancement and Grammarly for proofreading. The authors subsequently reviewed and verified all AI-assisted content for accuracy, originality, and compliance with academic and ethical standards. The authors take full responsibility for the content and interpretations presented in this manuscript.

If no GenAI technology was used, the authors may state:

Declaration of Generative AI Use: The authors declare that no Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation of this manuscript.

3. Use of Generative AI by the Editorial Team

The Editorial Team of Delta: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika must protect the confidentiality, intellectual property, and personal information contained in all submitted manuscripts and related documents.

Editors and editorial staff must not upload, copy, transmit, or provide any part of an unpublished manuscript, supplementary file, author response, reviewer report, or editorial correspondence to a publicly accessible or unauthorized AI system.

The Editorial Team may use AI-assisted technologies only for limited and non-substantive administrative purposes when:

  • The technology has been officially authorized by the journal or publisher;
  • Appropriate confidentiality, privacy, and data-security safeguards are in place;
  • No confidential manuscript content or personal information is disclosed;
  • The use does not involve scientific evaluation or publication decisions; and
  • All AI-assisted outputs are reviewed and verified by a responsible human editor.

Permitted administrative purposes may include workflow organization, scheduling, technical formatting assistance, or preparation of general correspondence that does not contain confidential manuscript information.

Editors and editorial staff must not use GenAI to:

  • Assess the scientific quality, originality, novelty, significance, or methodological validity of a manuscript;
  • Evaluate mathematical arguments, learning designs, instruments, statistical analyses, or research findings;
  • Generate substantive editorial evaluations or decision letters;
  • Decide whether a manuscript should be accepted, revised, rejected, or sent for peer review;
  • Replace human judgment in selecting reviewers or resolving conflicting review reports; or
  • Determine plagiarism, research misconduct, or undisclosed AI use solely on the basis of an automated AI-detection tool.

AI-detection results must not be treated as conclusive evidence of misconduct. Any concern regarding AI use must be examined through an appropriate editorial inquiry and supported by verifiable evidence.

All editorial decisions must be made by qualified human editors. The Editor-in-Chief and the assigned editor remain fully responsible for the fairness, accuracy, confidentiality, and integrity of the editorial process.

4. Prohibition of Generative AI Use by Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers of Delta: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika are prohibited from using GenAI or AI-assisted technologies in any part of the manuscript-review process.

Reviewers must not upload, copy, submit, or disclose a manuscript, abstract, supplementary file, figure, table, dataset, author response, or other confidential material to an AI system.

Reviewers must not use GenAI to:

  • Read, translate, summarize, interpret, or evaluate a submitted manuscript;
  • Assess its novelty, theoretical contribution, methodology, validity, findings, or implications;
  • Evaluate mathematical content, instruments, statistical analyses, or educational interventions;
  • Generate, revise, translate, or paraphrase reviewer comments;
  • Formulate criticisms, questions, recommendations, or publication decisions; or
  • Detect plagiarism, data manipulation, fabricated references, or AI-generated content independently of procedures authorized by the journal.

Peer-review reports must represent the reviewer’s own expertise, critical evaluation, and scholarly judgment. Reviewers remain personally accountable for the accuracy, fairness, originality, confidentiality, and professional quality of their reports.

A reviewer who cannot complete the evaluation without using GenAI should decline the review invitation. If a reviewer has inadvertently submitted confidential material to an AI system, the reviewer must immediately notify the assigned editor and discontinue the review.

5. Non-Compliance and Editorial Action

Failure to comply with this policy may be considered a breach of publication ethics.

Depending on the nature and severity of the violation, Union: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika may:

  • Request clarification or a formal declaration of AI use;
  • Require correction, revision, or removal of AI-generated material;
  • Reject or withdraw a submitted manuscript;
  • Disregard or invalidate a peer-review report;
  • Remove an editor or reviewer from the relevant editorial process;
  • Publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction; or
  • Refer suspected serious misconduct to the relevant institution.

All cases will be handled fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with the journal’s publication-ethics procedures.

6. Policy Updates

Because GenAI technologies and related ethical standards continue to develop, Delta: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika may review and update this policy periodically. Authors, editors, editorial staff, and peer reviewers are responsible for consulting the most recent version of this policy before participating in the journal’s publication process.